Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

EarlG

(22,639 posts)
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 01:52 PM Dec 9

Post-election DU upgrades and news

This is a long announcement. Please read on for news about DU and social media, discussions about the future of the Democratic Party on DU, and an update to DU's post footer buttons.

Hello everyone,

Well, it's been about a month since the election, and like everyone else here, the results hit me pretty hard, personally. I must admit that it's taken me some time to process things. I was not as shocked as I was after the 2016 election -- when we all felt that there was no way America could elect someone like Trump -- but given everything that's happened since he was elected the first time, it's clear that a second Trump presidency is going to be significantly worse than the first one (which was already appalling).

But if DU wasn't created for times like this, then I don't know what it was created for. When we launched the site in 2001, the media landscape was absolutely dominated by right-wing news talk radio, and we wanted to use the then-new technology of the Internet to push back, and provide a space for those on the left to talk free and clear of right-wing interruptions. DU is no longer new technology, but its purpose remains the same.

So with that said, here's some news about where we go from here. The three important things I want to talk about in this post are social media on DU (and DU on social media), the future of the Democratic Party, and some post-election DU software upgrades.


Social media

X/Twitter and Bluesky

Post-election, it has become clear that social media is more important than ever in our political landscape. As such, we are making some changes in this area on DU.

First, we plan to remove X/Twitter embeds from DU. Since liberal Twitter seems to be moving over to Bluesky, we plan to replace X/Twitter embeds and X/Twitter sharing with Bluesky. This does not mean that X/Twitter is banned from DU. It just means that -- if everything goes according to plan -- links to tweets will no longer embed as tweets on DU, they will simply show up as links. Meanwhile Bluesky links will show up as embedded posts.

In addition, we are removing X/Twitter from the Share options on DU OPs. That button will be replaced with a Share to Bluesky button.

Unfortunately, embedding Bluesky posts is not as straightforward as we had hoped, and we're not sure yet if we can get it to work. If we can, we will announce the switch from X/Twitter to Bluesky embeds when it happens. If we can't, we'll decide whether to continue with X/Twitter embeds or not (we are leaning towards removing them).

In the meantime, the Share to Bluesky button will be available when we release our new software patch tomorrow (see below for details).

DU on social media

DU has had Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter accounts for years. However, the only thing I ever used them for was posting my Pic Of The Moment, which I have not produced in a while, and which I'm still figuring out how (or whether) to continue. We have not used our Twitter account since Elon Musk bought Twitter, and I consider that account effectively irrelevant.

DU does have an unused Mastodon account, and I recently created a Bluesky account, which is also as yet unused.

The simple fact is this: I suck at social media. I don't have personal social media accounts. I don't care about social media in the slightest. But I don't think that should stop DU from having active, effective social media accounts. I know that there are lots of people on DU who are essentially experts at social media, who could actually turn our social media accounts into a force for good.

So I'm just going to put this on the table and leave it for further discussion: I'm considering asking for volunteers to help manage DU's social media accounts. If you're the kind of person who likes social media, is good at it, and has an idea for what DU could do with its current social media accounts, I could use your help. If you're interested in exploring this idea further, please reply to let me know.


The future of the Democratic Party

We have entered a new political era. While Donald Trump trashes our societal norms and government institutions, our old leaders are aging out, and a new crop of younger Democrats will soon rise to the top. Donald Trump will be a lame duck as soon as he takes office, and it surely won't be long before talk turns to the subject of who will run for president in 2028.

To be clear, I'm not suggesting that we need a forum to discuss the 2028 Democratic presidential primaries. That is a long, long way off. However, I'm suggesting that we might need a dedicated space to talk about the future of the party, and where we go from here. DU was recently operating under General Election rules, meaning that DUers must support our presidential nominee, and in the age of Trump my observation has been that DUers have been less tolerant of criticism of Democratic politicians -- understandably so.

However, I think that it would not be unhealthy to provide a space for discussion of where the Party should go next. These conversations may not be easy, but I do not think we should be afraid to have them, and I think they can be done in a civil manner. If you have an opinion on whether we should consider a new forum for these discussions, please let me know in reply to this thread. I'll see what the response looks like, and if it's something that seems wanted or needed, I'll open a new thread to discuss it separately.


Post-election DU software upgrades

Tomorrow, we are releasing a new software patch which makes some changes to the footer buttons on posts. (We were hoping to make these changes prior to the election, but ran out of time.) These are not significant changes, but they do streamline the buttons somewhat, and also add some additional functionality which people have been asking for.

Please note that the examples below are shown in DU's default mode, but if you use Night Mode or Skinner Mode, the buttons will also be updated appropriately.

New OP footer buttons -- when looking at someone else's OP

One purpose of this upgrade is to improve the visibility of the Share button. There's obviously a ton of great info on DU, and we think it should get shared more widely on social media. So we've given the Share button a more prominent placement.



But what about the Edit button, and how do you self-delete, or add/remove Journal entries? Well...

New OP footer buttons -- when looking at your own OP

When you are looking at one of your own posts, the new Options button will appear. This is essentially a re-branding of the "Powers" button. (The "Powers" button was a holdover from DU3, because it's what we called that button when it was used by Hosts and MIRT, but we think Options is more intuitive.)



This button will not be available unless you are looking at one of your own posts. When you are looking at one of your own posts and the Options button is available, clicking on it will allow you to edit, self-delete, or add/remove the post as a Journal entry.

(Note for Forum Hosts and MIRT members: The Options button replaces the Powers button, so you will find all your current abilities by clicking the Options button. When you see the Options button on someone else's post, it will appear as a normal grey button. On your own posts, it will be green as in the screenshots above.)

New reply footer buttons

Everything mentioned above about the Options button also applies to replies. (In the examples below, you won't see the Options button, but if you're looking at your own post, you will.) In addition, we have improved the Rec function on replies by separating the rec count from the rec button. This change will allow you to click through and see who has recommended a reply, just as you can do with an OP.

When a reply has not been recommended



When you have recommended a reply



Clicking the Rec button will add a rec (or remove it if you already rec'd and changed your mind). Clicking the rec count will take you to the post in single-post mode, which will display the list of who rec'd it.

We plan to update the buttons on Tuesday afternoon, December 10, 2024, at around 4pm ET. This will hopefully be fairly seamless, with only a brief moment of downtime. I'll make an additional announcement tomorrow right before we do it. Please note that when we launch this patch, as with every change we make to the software, there's a strong chance that it will require some bugfixes and cleanup.

I think that's all for now! Thanks for reading.

EarlG, on behalf of Elad -- the DU Administrators
206 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Post-election DU upgrades and news (Original Post) EarlG Dec 9 OP
THANK YOU FOR REMOVING XHITTER!!!!!! Maru Kitteh Dec 9 #1
Yeah a Big FU to mskhead... I like it! Cha Dec 9 #20
At last! Thank you. Jit423 Dec 9 #117
I DISAGREE, and I'm sure I'm not alone. Those who dislike the Twitter embeds Jack Valentino Dec 9 #161
I agree. There's still a lot of good stuff on X.a lot of prominent people still use it. kerry-is-my-prez Dec 10 #175
I would like to see a separate forum in where the Party should go next kerry-is-my-prez Dec 10 #176
Dont support fascism by supporting X-itter Flatrat Dec 10 #182
You support the global oligarchy of Musk as you wish. Democrats should not help you, and Maru Kitteh Dec 10 #187
Oopsy ... kooth Dec 9 #2
Fixed EarlG Dec 9 #7
Dec 11 dweller Dec 9 #3
I like the idea of the Democratic Party Forum separate from General relayerbob Dec 9 #4
Not very nuanced about Blue but you're right... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #65
Here it is relayerbob Dec 9 #121
Got it! ... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #139
I don't even know what that is relayerbob Dec 9 #157
Interesting! I'm glad... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #160
The only reason I originally joined Xitter relayerbob Dec 9 #163
A question for you relayerbob Dec 10 #186
Hi! 👋 littlemissmartypants Dec 10 #188
Understood relayerbob Dec 10 #189
Ok, then... littlemissmartypants Dec 10 #190
Thanks, but .... relayerbob Dec 10 #192
I don't want Threads Facebook or IG embeds -- those platforms censor Dems. live love laugh Dec 9 #74
what is IG? nt orleans Dec 9 #98
Probably Instagram. nt Shipwack Dec 9 #119
I've never once had a post blocked on either FB or Threads (I don't use IG) relayerbob Dec 9 #122
It's not blocking that matters on algorithmic platforms. Voltaire2 Dec 9 #138
All great info, BUT - Tuesday is the 10th, not the 11th. n/t intheflow Dec 9 #5
Thank you, EarlG. Elessar Zappa Dec 9 #6
Thank you guys, you are all awesome. n/t SheilaAnn Dec 9 #8
First of all Thank You for all your work... MiHale Dec 9 #9
This message was self-deleted by its author eggplant Dec 9 #10
Yes, I think providing a new forum for the future of the Democratic NewHendoLib Dec 9 #11
Agree, but I'd like to see it in General Discussion n/t leftstreet Dec 9 #19
I'm not sure what you mean. ShazzieB Dec 9 #89
Doggone changes keithbvadu2 Dec 9 #12
Thank you, EarlG and elad, as always, for everything. You guys rock. Aristus Dec 9 #13
Thank you for the updates! ZDU Dec 9 #14
Cool beans! 2naSalit Dec 9 #15
Thanks for the update BumRushDaShow Dec 9 #16
I support the proposed changes! cilla4progress Dec 9 #17
Thank you for all you do! When looking at the button updates woodsprite Dec 9 #18
I would prefer a separate forum for the "new direction" discussions. W_HAMILTON Dec 9 #21
Count me in on being for the new forum for discussing the Democratic Party's future. ificandream Dec 9 #22
Any plans to allow TikTok embeds, like with YouTube videos? JoseBalow Dec 9 #23
Thanks, Guys orangecrush Dec 9 #24
This place keeps me sane, too! calimary Dec 10 #177
Thank you for your hard work! Dennis Donovan Dec 9 #25
Thanks for all the hard work. mahatmakanejeeves Dec 9 #26
What is your Bluesky handle? /nt Sweet Freedom Dec 9 #27
Look for the logo... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #69
Thanks for posting that link red dog 1 Dec 9 #82
Yes it's @demunderground.bsky.social EarlG Dec 9 #106
Got it, thanks. red dog 1 Dec 9 #110
You should edit your profile and put Democratic Underground as the display name. nt. Voltaire2 Dec 10 #193
Thanks! Followed. :) /nt Sweet Freedom Dec 12 #205
Mahalo for DU, EarlG & Elad and Cha Dec 9 #28
Count me in on being in favor of the new forum! Polybius Dec 9 #29
Good to read this as when I started, I was fearing something else entirely... hlthe2b Dec 9 #30
Yes, I think we should have a new thread to discuss where the Democratic Party is going h2ebits Dec 9 #31
great work, amazing DoBW Dec 9 #32
There are good rightful people that are staying on X. The Grand Illuminist Dec 9 #33
She's on blue. littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #70
She still posts on X as well. The Grand Illuminist Dec 9 #72
This message was self-deleted by its author littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #87
It is literally a fascist propaganda organization. Voltaire2 Dec 10 #180
It can also be a great tool The Grand Illuminist Dec 10 #185
Yes of course you are off 'fighting the good fight'. Voltaire2 Dec 10 #191
👍 underpants Dec 9 #34
Under POWERS/OPTIONS can we have a "Delete Trump" option? Thanks in advance. usonian Dec 9 #35
Keep it all in GD for now Renew Deal Dec 9 #36
Disagree. GD moves too fast... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #73
The problem is that if you move it out, people won't see them Renew Deal Dec 9 #90
They will if you make it a main board Polybius Dec 9 #93
Sinking and dying on the vine... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #112
I agree wholeheartedly. Silver Gaia Dec 10 #168
TY! ❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 10 #170
You are most welcome. Thank you for speaking up! Silver Gaia Dec 10 #178
TY! 😘 We sure do need it more than ever! ❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 10 #179
I tend to agree. returnee Dec 9 #102
To be clear this would be a new top-level forum EarlG Dec 9 #108
Thank you, EarlG and Elad. Where would we be without you? Scrivener7 Dec 9 #37
I have no idea if you can, but write the forum you propose in such a way Prairie_Seagull Dec 9 #38
Suggest you do NOT drop you Twitter account Maeve Dec 9 #39
Agree. Place hold the DU moniker on xitter. ... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #76
I'm not closing the DU Twitter account for the reason you state EarlG Dec 9 #107
This message was self-deleted by its author littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #143
i recommend you get an account at blue sky before someone takes the name. nt orleans Dec 9 #153
I'm in fir happy feet Dec 9 #40
Iagree with the new forum idea senseandsensibility Dec 9 #41
Thanks for posting this, senseandsensibility. My feelings exactly! BComplex Dec 9 #91
This message was self-deleted by its author Prairie_Seagull Dec 9 #42
I'm in for happy feet Dec 9 #43
I love ALL of it. I recommend Buffer for whoever manages DU accounts on socials CousinIT Dec 9 #44
I found this comparison helpful... ultralite001 Dec 9 #78
SoMe Bookmark ❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #80
You're welcome... ultralite001 Dec 9 #81
Bookmark. SoMe rec. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #79
I actually do use Buffer already EarlG Dec 9 #109
I'm sure someone on DU can help! We have mods...we can have social media... CousinIT Dec 9 #124
I volunteer if you'd like my help. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #145
I'm also a social media non-participant but,... Think. Again. Dec 9 #150
Thank you, and I'm all for a forum for discussing our party's future. femmedem Dec 9 #45
I fully support a forum where people can discuss the future of the party, Seeking Serenity Dec 9 #46
This is one of my biggest fears... slightlv Dec 9 #140
I support a forum like that as well DSandra Dec 9 #149
I am all in on a separate Forum to discuss WheelWalker Dec 9 #47
I like the future of the Democratic party forum Lulu KC Dec 9 #48
I like the idea of a forum about the future of the Democratic Party and where we might go from here. red dog 1 Dec 9 #49
He has four accounts on blue... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #148
Thanks, I didn't know that. red dog 1 Dec 11 #200
if x gets switched out with blue sky maybe you could find something there orleans Dec 9 #158
I've tried to thank you for posting that link 3 times, with no luck. red dog 1 Dec 11 #201
awww... well, thank you for being so persistent. this thank you went through and you're welcome orleans Dec 11 #203
Thank you, EarlG and all DU Admins evolves Dec 9 #50
I'm in favor of a new forum to discuss the future of the Democratic Party. yardwork Dec 9 #51
I definitely think we need a forum for discussions on the Democratic Party's future. LoisB Dec 9 #52
Thank you so much! 💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Dec 9 #53
I'm really glad you're not into social media... :- nt LAS14 Dec 9 #54
lol. yeah, that gives him waay more time to focus on us here! orleans Dec 9 #159
Another vote for a "Future of the Democratic Party " forum Fiendish Thingy Dec 9 #55
Question about X/Twitter embeds Different Drummer Dec 9 #56
All. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #77
I agree with you that we need to discuss where the Party goes from here. kentuck Dec 9 #57
THANKS FOR ALL YOUR HARD WORK AND DEDICATION!! ailsagirl Dec 9 #58
These are great changes... Spazito Dec 9 #59
sounds good. thanks for all you do Kali Dec 9 #60
I like the idea for the separate forum. greatauntoftriplets Dec 9 #61
Thanks for the update, EarlG, and for everything you and Elad are doing. And add me to the DUers highplainsdem Dec 9 #62
Got it. Thanks! Iggo Dec 9 #63
Just don't name the new forum "JackPine Radical". nt eppur_se_muova Dec 9 #64
Excellent! Thank you so much. applegrove Dec 9 #66
Thanks EarlG malaise Dec 9 #67
Thank you, Earl, Mr.Bill Dec 9 #68
Thank you for all you do dlk Dec 9 #71
Thanks for EVERYTHING! elleng Dec 9 #75
I am definitely on board montanacowboy Dec 9 #83
For the proposed "future-of-the-Democratic-party" forum, posting rules will have to be relaxed significant;y SpankMe Dec 9 #84
DU has never, ever been a "free speech" forum EarlG Dec 9 #111
❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #142
Support that discussions of where the Party should go next... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #85
"Won't use the reply rec anymore with the change. I like that it's anonymous." - Me too: I like the anonymity nmmi Dec 9 #164
I'm glad to know that I'm not the only one. ... littlemissmartypants Dec 10 #169
I suppose it will be retroactive too, so that all one's reply recs will be exposed since the beginning of DU4 nmmi Dec 10 #173
I hope it's retroactive JoseBalow Dec 10 #172
New forum for dem party needed - and may attract new members TBF Dec 9 #86
Also a fan of Bluesky - TBF Dec 9 #88
Thanks Earl. I feel pumped already! GreenWave Dec 9 #92
Like! Like! Like! Mike Nelson Dec 9 #94
Thank you. Blue Dawn Dec 9 #95
Great, EarlG and Elad! Eugene Dec 9 #96
Thank you for all you do solara Dec 9 #97
I'm in favor of anything that gives that MFer MuskRat the finger!! InAbLuEsTaTe Dec 9 #99
I fully support a forum where the future of virgdem Dec 9 #100
Add another vote in favor of a "future of the Democratic Party" forum with looser rules in some areas JHB Dec 9 #101
I support a new forum to discuss The future of the Democratic Party. quaint Dec 9 #103
Thank you for removing Twitter MustLoveBeagles Dec 9 #104
I have shyed away from posting in DU since the election because the direction William769 Dec 9 #105
New forum. Magoo48 Dec 9 #113
Awesome Windy Apple Dec 9 #114
Great news! Lunabell Dec 9 #115
Strongly agree with shunning Xtwitter. SCantiGOP Dec 9 #116
all good stuff! Takket Dec 9 #118
Thanks, and I also support the new forum idea. nt Shipwack Dec 9 #120
Thank you, and yes to a separate forum for moving the party forward. GPV Dec 9 #123
We need the ability to analyze the paths forward for the Democratic Party. Hellbound Hellhound Dec 9 #125
I don't know if you've... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #141
I'm not saying a lawless zone. Just one without juries. Hellbound Hellhound Dec 9 #147
I think any place... littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #151
That's all fair. You and Earl G know more than I. Hellbound Hellhound Dec 9 #154
❤️ littlemissmartypants Dec 9 #155
❤️ nt Hellbound Hellhound Dec 9 #156
Regarding discussion of the Party etc Dyedinthewoolliberal Dec 9 #126
DU - Now More Than Ever! Snarkoleptic Dec 9 #127
Thanks EarlG bdamomma Dec 9 #128
Hard vote for a separate forum thread for issues concerning the party Cheezoholic Dec 9 #129
X is in the Trash. MagaSmash Dec 9 #130
Here here keepthemhonestO Dec 9 #131
Seem like good ideas Cosmo Blues Dec 9 #132
This must have been... oldsoldierfadingfast Dec 9 #133
EarlG.............. Upthevibe Dec 9 #134
Great job, and I'd like to see the new forum HereForTheParty Dec 9 #135
All excellent moves forward!! Moosepoop Dec 9 #136
Following This Thread Baron2024 Dec 9 #137
+1 on the Party Direction Forum Bristlecone Dec 9 #144
A forum about the future of the party- YES! 👍 RainCaster Dec 9 #146
I support a new forum as well for discussions DSandra Dec 9 #152
I will be disappointed if Twitter embeds no longer appear, regardless of what happens Jack Valentino Dec 9 #162
Thank you for all you do ... and yes, I think a dedicated forum for the future of the party is a great idea fishwax Dec 9 #165
GREAT IDEA about enlisting some DUers to administrate the site's social media accounts! Jack Valentino Dec 9 #166
Thanks for all your efforts at B.See Dec 9 #167
Thank you EarlG and team. Hope22 Dec 10 #171
K&R! burrowowl Dec 10 #174
Thank you, EarlG and Elad! gademocrat7 Dec 10 #181
New forum, no Twitter ramapo Dec 10 #183
I left X when he allowed the Nazis back sellitman Dec 10 #184
Zelenskyy's Syria statement today is a Tweet Bobstandard Dec 10 #194
Yes, I'm all for a Future of the Unified Democratic Party Forum, the sooner the better. ancianita Dec 10 #195
Has the update happened? I'm not seeing the new stuff yet. CousinIT Dec 10 #196
Thanks for all you do! A couple thoughts: FireUpChips10 Dec 10 #197
I like the idea of a forum. We just lost an election to a convicted felon. boston bean Dec 11 #198
A separate forum would become an alert-drenched slapfest Sympthsical Dec 11 #199
Well said. On the one hand, it would be 'interesting' for some of us Abolishinist Dec 11 #202
We need a forum for critique. carpetbagger Dec 12 #204
Geriatric Democratic Leadership Refuse to Step Aside devans00 Dec 17 #206

Jack Valentino

(1,510 posts)
161. I DISAGREE, and I'm sure I'm not alone. Those who dislike the Twitter embeds
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:45 PM
Dec 9

just seem to be LOUDER and complain incessantly about it!

There are still plenty of liberals on Twitter, and I'm one of them. I appreciate being able to see and read the Twitter embeds without having to click-through to a link.

I really HATE when people post a "link" and nothing else. This change would convert every Twitter post to yet another "link" with nothing else.

Hell, rather than removing Twitter embeds, I would like to see it made impossible to post a stand-alone link without a summary of said links, with a minimum character requirement!

Flatrat

(165 posts)
182. Dont support fascism by supporting X-itter
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 08:30 AM
Dec 10

>There are still plenty of liberals on Twitter, and I'm one of them. I appreciate being able to see and read the Twitter embeds without having to click-through to a link.

That becomes less true daily as more people flee the cesspool. Don't enable that one particular illegal immigrant. He is in a position to much damage to democracy with his money.

Lets not go back.

Maru Kitteh

(29,234 posts)
187. You support the global oligarchy of Musk as you wish. Democrats should not help you, and
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 11:19 AM
Dec 10

the majority of Democrats here understand that rather clearly.

relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
4. I like the idea of the Democratic Party Forum separate from General
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:00 PM
Dec 9

It will keep some of the noise level down there, and allow to have a focussed platform to discuss changes that clearly need to be implemented.

I would like to see Threads embeds also, Bluesky and Threads serve different purposes and audiences. I am on both, but see that Threads is a more one-on-one experience, whereas Bluesky is more giant accounts trying to get follows. Just IMO, YMMV. But ... getting both would be good and getting rid of Xitter, would be the best.

And thanks for all the hard work!

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
65. Not very nuanced about Blue but you're right...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:21 PM
Dec 9

MMV.

What's your Bluesky handle?

You can follow me @2diamondeyes.bsky.social

And no Suckerberg for me. No Threads sharing for data thieves. Respectfully.

❤️

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
139. Got it! ...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:26 PM
Dec 9

I'm having trouble reconciling your statement that

"Bluesky is more giant accounts trying to get follows."


And that your handle came up in search as part of a list for a #FBR train where posters agree to follow back everyone on a list provided by a third party through what are known as Follow Back Parties.

I personally would rather individually vet people before I follow them.

Did you join the list to avoid starter packs? Do you have history with the list maker, Meidas Sassy? Do you recommend them? Do you follow any from the train? Have you found the accounts you follow from the train ok?

I followed a few from a #FBR that came with a picture I reposted. Often those lists come with AI pictures.

Adding pictures is one of the tricks used in social media networks generally to drive engagement. Research in social media strongly supports that increased engagement from users happens when graphics are present regardless of the accuracy of the information provided in them.

Most memes are worthless to me with no source. AI art theft is also somewhat repugnant to me but lots of posters are creating AI graphics to drive engagement.

That picture I liked and reposted is from user Skye. He's one of what I call "working" accounts. Those accounts seem to have limited conversational participation but tend to post #FBR lists and other things they manufacture from the accounts on the site. Like the one you popped up on.

They're everywhere. Many refer to themselves as part of the #BlueCrew. They appear to be trying to start a strong base where they might launch monetization later if blue goes in that direction. Right now, they claim that they aren’t. Time will tell.

I belong to one Team Pete starter pack list. I am also one of a few fortunate to be assisting with beta testing an application associated with the site.

Overall, my experience with blue has been very pleasant. I'll look forward to hearing more about your experience.


Thanks for your reply and for sharing your account there with me, relayerbob.

❤️pants



relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
157. I don't even know what that is
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:27 PM
Dec 9

I've never agreed to be on any #FBR thing, and I always vet who I'm following, hence why I don't have many on my list, in comparison to others. Apparently, in their zeal to create followings, some people have no problems with just grabbing names and including them on lists. Bluecrew started on Xitter, and I sorta followed that, but they just were fishing for headcount, not actually providing any real interaction, nor activism, as I had hoped.

As far as my comment about big accounts, the majority of what I seem to see there are large accounts jonseing to get more followers, and/or marketing. What you call "working" accounts. In some cases, people just post nonsense posts, or as you note, worthless memes or AI art to generate engagement, and follower fishing. I don't do that. My accounts grow organically, from people I like to converse with, or have something in common with.

An example from right now:

‪Marc Elias‬ ‪@marcelias.bsky.social‬
·
4h
Closing in on 500k.👀
------
I''ve never had him (or even seen him) respond to comments, and that holds true a good many "celebrities" there, whereas on Threads, for example, I've had interactions with people like Jeri Ryan, Rick Wilson, various politicians and others, as well as just regular folk. Threads focusses on interaction and engagement, not numbers of followers. If you want your account to be seen, you interact on a regular basis, and the more interaction, the more people interact back. I've sortof given up on commenting on Bluesky, as I've only ever gotten a few "likes" and almost no responses to anything. On Threads, I've had replies with well over 1000 "likes", while my account there is somewhat larger, it is pretty small by social media standards.




littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
160. Interesting! I'm glad...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:34 PM
Dec 9

You're enjoying threads. I don't do anything Zuckerberg. But thanks for the reply! ❤️

relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
163. The only reason I originally joined Xitter
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:55 PM
Dec 9

was for Ukraine news, and it's still one of the things I watch most closely. Social media always beats the MSM to the news these days. Gotta watch out for what is real, of course, haha, but then again, the MSM posts nonsense all the time

relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
186. A question for you
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 10:57 AM
Dec 10

Do you know how to cut off a follower without blocking them on Bluesky? There are folks I don't really want following me, that I haven't followed back. I don't see a point in blocking them, as they don't seem dangerous or MAGA, but just don't want them in my follow list.

Actually, two questions - is there a reason you didn't follow me back?

Thanks,

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
188. Hi! 👋
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:18 PM
Dec 10

Sorry, I didn't follow you. I have my notifications shut off, and when I checked them, I had twenty+ new followers overnight. I get twenty-five or more notifications every couple of hours from the application that I'm beta testing, and I'm behind on my own notifications. I piddled around reading my discover, following feeds, and adding some accounts to my lists. I came over here to create a post (which I screwed up), and then I checked my replies & found yours.

So...Do you not want the follower to follow you? Not read your posts? Or just not appear on your followers list? I mean, what do you want to be the final result? LMK & I'll try my best.

❤️

relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
189. Understood
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:32 PM
Dec 10

Yes, the notification system there is a little opaque, I just didn’t want it to be something I said, lol.

Mostly, I just want them not to appear in my followers list. I actually look at that to vet people sometimes (look at their followers and who they follow), and in some cases, just don’t want certain accounts that I believe might be trolls or organizations that I don’t want blocked, to be seen. I don’t care if they see me, and may occasionally have something of interest to me, so I don’t want to block them. Meta and twitter made it really easy, you just click and remove them from the followers list, and they are gone without notification to the person being “unfriended”.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
190. Ok, then...
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:38 PM
Dec 10

Block The Follower is what you don't want

Remove The Follower can be done...
Using this method will remove a follower from your list of Bluesky followers, but they will still be able to see your posts. This method works on any kind of device - Android, iPhone, Computer, etc. To remove a follower, follow these steps:

Login to Bluesky using App or website
●Go to your profile page.
●Click on the "Followers" tab.
●Find the follower that you want to remove.
●Click on the "Remove" button.
This will remove the follower from your list of followers, but they will still be able to see your posts.

Block is what disables their ability to read and interact. If that's what you want then you have to use block. But my understanding is you want the former.

Good luck! 🍀🤞

❤️

relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
192. Thanks, but ....
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 01:16 PM
Dec 10

I've looked at that repeatedly, and hoped there was an update I had missed. Nope. There is no "Remove" button on the browser version. I don't use the app, so I guess I'll have to install that and try it.

Update: Not available on the iPhone app, either. All I see is a Follow Back button, and in their account, all that is there is "Add to lists, Mute, Block, Report".

Oh well, though you were correct in your interpretation.

relayerbob

(7,071 posts)
122. I've never once had a post blocked on either FB or Threads (I don't use IG)
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 06:21 PM
Dec 9

And while I see people complaining about it, at the same time, I see the exact posts they claim have been deleted. There are a lot of paranoid folks on all ends of the spectrum.

Voltaire2

(14,880 posts)
138. It's not blocking that matters on algorithmic platforms.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:24 PM
Dec 9

It is your posts visibility ranking in the algorithm. All of these platforms suppress non-Maga messaging by ranking bias.

Elessar Zappa

(16,092 posts)
6. Thank you, EarlG.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:01 PM
Dec 9

I do like the idea of a forum where constructive discussion of the party and its future can be had with constructive criticism allowed, as long as it doesn’t turn ugly. I also like the social media idea although I, too, suck at it so can’t be much of a help. But anyway, keep up the great work! I’ve been here since I was 19 in 2003 and plan to continue posting until I die or the site goes offline lol.

MiHale

(10,896 posts)
9. First of all Thank You for all your work...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:03 PM
Dec 9

2nd…I do believe that a separate forum for the ‘ Direction of the Party’ would a good idea. Keep it away from GD, things could get out of hand there.

Response to EarlG (Original post)

NewHendoLib

(60,572 posts)
11. Yes, I think providing a new forum for the future of the Democratic
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:04 PM
Dec 9

Party is a great idea I'd like to see implemented

ShazzieB

(18,927 posts)
89. I'm not sure what you mean.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:01 PM
Dec 9

EarlG is proposing to create a new forum for discussing the future of the party. Are you in favor of that, or you saying saying all of that should stay in GD? It's an either/or choice.

For the record, I'm in favor of the new forum. GD is already enough of a grab bag as it is, imo.

Aristus

(68,658 posts)
13. Thank you, EarlG and elad, as always, for everything. You guys rock.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:08 PM
Dec 9

To quote Stephen Hopkins from the musical "1776": "In all my years, I've never seen, heard, nor smelled an issue so dangerous it couldn't be talked about."

Let's absolutely have a forum on the 2028 race and what Democrats should do to win it.

ZDU

(78 posts)
14. Thank you for the updates!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:08 PM
Dec 9

Casting my vote towards a more socially minded, progressive looking, future ready Democratic party. Onwards! Upwards! 🗳️.

BumRushDaShow

(144,287 posts)
16. Thanks for the update
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:11 PM
Dec 9

and the "Options" for "Powers" is definitely a good change 'cause I know a bunch of folks had no idea where "self-delete" was.

Look forward to the updates!

I would also like to see something like a "2024 Post Mortem" forum/group similar to the 2016 one, to eventually move the election discussion. That way a more liberal SOP could be deployed to allow more "critique" that might otherwise generate hides as TOS violations... but then with the expectation that this type of critique would be kept THERE versus elsewhere.

cilla4progress

(25,983 posts)
17. I support the proposed changes!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:12 PM
Dec 9

Getting rid of links to x.

And especially the new forum / fora.

I agree we need to look to the future for Dem leadership! I am particularly drawn to the young leaders of color - AOC, Jasmine Crockett, Maxwell Frost and others.

Thank you EarlG and all admins!!!

woodsprite

(12,247 posts)
18. Thank you for all you do! When looking at the button updates
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:12 PM
Dec 9

I just had one thought. In my workgroup we're very careful where we use the color red. Red seems like it would be an 'Alert' color rather than a 'Rec' color. Maybe green, blue, purple, even black would work since the text and edge are black and wold stay the same, just add the background color when the state changes?

Like I said, it was just something to think about.

Thank you again, EarlG!

ificandream

(10,767 posts)
22. Count me in on being for the new forum for discussing the Democratic Party's future.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:16 PM
Dec 9

I think this is an excellent idea.

calimary

(84,638 posts)
177. This place keeps me sane, too!
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 04:14 AM
Dec 10

And even though a lot of the technical talk here is hard to understand (at least for me), I appreciate YOUR work in creating a safe and supportive place for folks like me to vent, learn, expand, gain solidarity and wisdom! Thanks so So SO Much!!!

Dennis Donovan

(27,492 posts)
25. Thank you for your hard work!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:18 PM
Dec 9

Just a suggestion. Please wait to remove Twitter's ability to render inside DU until you can get Bluesky to render. Twitter and Bluesky have two users (Aaron Rupar and Acyn) that post tons of videos on both Twitter and Bluesky, but are usually unavailable on YouTube. I'd hate to lose the ability to post videos from these particular Twitter/Bluesky users.

mahatmakanejeeves

(61,659 posts)
26. Thanks for all the hard work.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:19 PM
Dec 9

I have piles of links to Twitter accounts, from years gone by. It's no big deal if they don't embed. Folks who so choose can click on them to see what they're missing.

Thanks again, and good afternoon.

EarlG

(22,639 posts)
106. Yes it's @demunderground.bsky.social
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:21 PM
Dec 9

There are no posts yet because I haven't posted anything!

hlthe2b

(106,808 posts)
30. Good to read this as when I started, I was fearing something else entirely...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:24 PM
Dec 9

(I won't let my misplaced paranoia be given "print," but will just say I am relieved)...

Some great changes. I like not embedding X, but there are (unfortunately) still some important figures still posting there so I agree that it shouldn't be banned.

Kudos!

PS. I never knew where to post the question, but I'll ask it here. Do you ever hear from Skinner and if so, would he mind your giving us a little update on how he's doing?







h2ebits

(777 posts)
31. Yes, I think we should have a new thread to discuss where the Democratic Party is going
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:24 PM
Dec 9

"However, I think that it would not be unhealthy to provide a space for discussion of where the Party should go next. These conversations may not be easy, but I do not think we should be afraid to have them, and I think they can be done in a civil manner. If you have an opinion on whether we should consider a new forum for these discussions, please let me know in reply to this thread. I'll see what the response looks like, and if it's something that seems wanted or needed, I'll open a new thread to discuss it separately."
*********************************************************************************************************************************
Love your careful wording that it "would not be unhealthy." In fact, I believe that it is absolutely necessary that we pursue conversations on where the Democratic Party is going in order to fix its trajectory. By and large, my impressions are that a very bright group of people have made decisions based on their own bubble of knowledge and reality, which is a far cry from what "the people" actually see as their reality.

We are losing the information war.

Response to The Grand Illuminist (Reply #72)

Voltaire2

(14,880 posts)
191. Yes of course you are off 'fighting the good fight'.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:46 PM
Dec 10

lol. Whatever. I have no problem at all 'knowing the enemy' as their propaganda is everywhere.

usonian

(14,651 posts)
35. Under POWERS/OPTIONS can we have a "Delete Trump" option? Thanks in advance.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:30 PM
Dec 9

I make extensive use of Trashing and Ignoring.
NOT TO USERS: These do not work on the home page.

I also have browser extensions: “TrumpTrump” and “Firewall Trump” For what it’s worth.

And for all of us bummed out this Christmas Season:
Share with your ChrisoFascist friends:



Lots of love for DU friends.
Beer’s on me if you can find me.
Sadly, the Usonian HQ here is socked in with pea soup fog.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
73. Disagree. GD moves too fast...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:30 PM
Dec 9

Discussions sink like boulders and then duplicates abound. Wastes time and creates muddy discussions. No thank you. Respectfully.

❤️

Renew Deal

(83,082 posts)
90. The problem is that if you move it out, people won't see them
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:04 PM
Dec 9

So they die on the vine rather than sinking.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
112. Sinking and dying on the vine...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:37 PM
Dec 9

Are the same thing. Also, moving out what?

It appears that he's proposing that there be an entirely new forum/group created for discussion of the future of the Democratic Party.

GD has always been just a catch all. It's like a huge trash bin. You have to dig through it to find things. When you dig, you find the same things over and over.

Things move fast and poof, they're gone.

That doesn't seem very complimentary to thoughtful discussion to me.

How can a basic theme be pondered and discussed thoughtfully if you have to dig through multitudes of unrelated posts just to find the one you want?

I'd like to be able to find any thoughtful discussions on the future of the Democratic Party readily when I look for them.

If I can't, I'll be less likely to participate. I don't think I'm alone in that regard.

❤️

Silver Gaia

(4,915 posts)
168. I agree wholeheartedly.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:22 AM
Dec 10

A new forum for these discussions is the way to go. It's important to me as well that we be able to find these posts easily when we want to talk about these topics. By the time I sift through GD to find a conversation about this, chances are, I'd be too tired to say what I wanted to say. Some of us, like me, don't make OPs very often, but we do enjoy reading and commenting on others' OPs. Being able to find these posts when I want to find them would be a definite plus!

Silver Gaia

(4,915 posts)
178. You are most welcome. Thank you for speaking up!
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 04:16 AM
Dec 10

I also liked what you said here in post #73:

"Discussions sink like boulders and then duplicates abound. Wastes time and creates muddy discussions."

Absolutely. All the dupes can be maddening! These are the most important discussions we could have right now, and having them consolidated in one place would be a huge assist in creating focus and helping us organize coherently.

Doing this will NOT give these discussions less prominence. I'm sure the effect will be to give them more prominence.This will be high-level, I'm sure, so quite visible, not hidden away.

I trust that EarlG and elad know what they are doing and why. It will be a good thing! No, a great thing! We need this.

returnee

(333 posts)
102. I tend to agree.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:08 PM
Dec 9

This discussion is crucial and should not be isolated from the mainstream forums. I also see how thorny such discussions will likely be. I don’t think that can be avoided. I think it should be VERY clear on what is in and out of bounds for posting, whichever forum they’re in.

EarlG

(22,639 posts)
108. To be clear this would be a new top-level forum
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:24 PM
Dec 9

Like the old "GD: Politics," the primaries forums, and the post-mortem forums that we've had over the years. We would probably slot it in between GD and the Lounge. I would imagine that the forum would be converted to the next Primaries forum when the time is right.

Scrivener7

(53,216 posts)
37. Thank you, EarlG and Elad. Where would we be without you?
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:33 PM
Dec 9

Seriously, I hope you know what a lifeline you are in so many ways for so many people!

Prairie_Seagull

(3,817 posts)
38. I have no idea if you can, but write the forum you propose in such a way
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:33 PM
Dec 9

that it can easily be undone. May be like WWE in there. Cursing is one of my favorite pastimes. haha

Thanks for what you and Elad do.

Maeve

(43,046 posts)
39. Suggest you do NOT drop you Twitter account
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:35 PM
Dec 9

It would free up the name for trolls. Don't use it, but keep the account (got that from Bluesky users)
Yes to a place to talk about the future of the party, altho it may need something like moderation to work, at least at first. And maybe limit it to keep new trolls out.....
Thank you guys for giving us this place. We love you!!!!!!

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
76. Agree. Place hold the DU moniker on xitter. ...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:35 PM
Dec 9

Avoid a hijack of the DU Brand.

📣📣FYI FOR ALL READERS📣📣

Especially EG
Migrate X to blue
https://www.bluesky-migrate.com

tweetdeleter application
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=tweetdeleter&ko=-1&ia=web

❤️

EarlG

(22,639 posts)
107. I'm not closing the DU Twitter account for the reason you state
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:22 PM
Dec 9

Thanks -- I read the same info recently.

Response to EarlG (Reply #107)

happy feet

(1,122 posts)
40. I'm in fir
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:36 PM
Dec 9

Discussion of where we should go next. Looking fwd would be a good respite from what is.

senseandsensibility

(20,399 posts)
41. Iagree with the new forum idea
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:36 PM
Dec 9

I, for one, have been resisting sharing my honest feelings on DU since the election because I was afraid that I would be breaking the rules. But I have been extremely disappointed in the establishment Dems' response to the election results and their insistence on following old rules that went out the window decades ago as the rest of us feel abandoned.

BComplex

(9,156 posts)
91. Thanks for posting this, senseandsensibility. My feelings exactly!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:06 PM
Dec 9

I don't know how many posts I've written and then deleted since the election! I'm really looking forward to the new forum!

Response to EarlG (Original post)

happy feet

(1,122 posts)
43. I'm in for
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:38 PM
Dec 9

Discussion of where we should go next. Looking fwd would be a good respite from what is.

CousinIT

(10,491 posts)
44. I love ALL of it. I recommend Buffer for whoever manages DU accounts on socials
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:38 PM
Dec 9

Whatever social media platforms DU admins choose to use themselves, Buffer can post to multiple of them at once and allows you to format posts appropriately for each platform. You can post to up to three platforms on Buffer for free (Bluesky, Mastadon, and another, hopefully not X).

I'd also recommend using a separate (not your personal) account for Buffer. Instead, use a DU-dedicated one for posting to the three chosen platforms with Buffer and absolutely enable MFA on this account. The DU admins will have to work out how all this is synced up with the existing DU admin accounts on BlueSky, Mastadon, etc.

Whatever you do, secure it as much as possible and use Buffer or something like it to post once to all of them. It makes communication with our community on socials much more manageable for whoever does it.

ultralite001

(1,183 posts)
78. I found this comparison helpful...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:37 PM
Dec 9

Buffer v HootSuite

These social media management applications streamline the process of promoting your brand across various social media platforms...

https://www.forbes.com/advisor/business/software/buffer-vs-hootsuite/

EarlG

(22,639 posts)
109. I actually do use Buffer already
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:27 PM
Dec 9

I'm not sure if this has changed, but it used to be the only way I could post to Instagram from my PC.

The issue is not really with the management of DU's social media output -- it's with the content of the output itself. I only ever posted my Pic to our social media accounts, and I haven't made a Pic for a while. I think we could do a lot more with them than I was previously, but I don't do social media personally, so I'm pretty much in the dark about how best to use them.

CousinIT

(10,491 posts)
124. I'm sure someone on DU can help! We have mods...we can have social media...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 06:35 PM
Dec 9

... volunteers too, I hope.

Think. Again.

(19,131 posts)
150. I'm also a social media non-participant but,...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:10 PM
Dec 9

... perhaps just automating the Greatest Page posts so they randomly post to the various social sites would keep it simple and bring new eyes backward into this site, rather than risking kicking off numerous separate discussions happening elsewhere?

(If that even makes any sense.)

femmedem

(8,455 posts)
45. Thank you, and I'm all for a forum for discussing our party's future.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:39 PM
Dec 9

Yes, it needs to be civil. We need to respect a range of opinions, including where we think we've fallen short either in messaging or policies. And we need to be able to voice those opinions without fear of being alerted on for disparaging or not supporting Democrats. I love our Democratic Party; I served for a decade on our local Democratic Town Committee and have knocked on many a door for Democratic candidates. But after losing all three branches of the federal government, Democrats need broad, honest, visionary discussions about where we go from here.

Seeking Serenity

(3,080 posts)
46. I fully support a forum where people can discuss the future of the party,
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:43 PM
Dec 9

How it might change to meet changing conditions (because a party incapable of change or even honest self-reflection is doomed to calcification), etc, respectfully but honestly, without the ever-present fear of juries who will not abide any criticism of the party or its leaders, no matter how constructive the critique or in good faith it's presented.

Thanks!!

slightlv

(4,445 posts)
140. This is one of my biggest fears...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:32 PM
Dec 9

yippers... it could be a wild arena in a "Progress" forum. But, even when I think I have concrete criticisms about the party or a rep, I try to self censor the worst of it... even some ideas, themselves. It would be nice to have someplace to bring up a criticism and not be shot to hell for doing it. I will say, lately, I've not seen that so much... but I've also been staying mostly off anything "news" related, including DU, for my own mental health, and too many changes and issues in my own personal life right now.

Nothing against anyone that's posting anything here, just the headlines scare the crap out of me and jump my BP too high.

WheelWalker

(9,210 posts)
47. I am all in on a separate Forum to discuss
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:44 PM
Dec 9

New directions for the party. I'm glad I think you're doing a great job during difficult times and appreciate your commitment.

Lulu KC

(5,022 posts)
48. I like the future of the Democratic party forum
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:45 PM
Dec 9

I would hope that a lot of the hindsight about this year's election would find its way over there. It's a fine line between "bashing Democrats" and reflecting on what might have worked better without insulting people who did and will continue to do their very best.

All of this is good. Thanks for your leadership.

red dog 1

(29,550 posts)
49. I like the idea of a forum about the future of the Democratic Party and where we might go from here.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:46 PM
Dec 9

Last edited Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:40 PM - Edit history (5)

It could be a place where we could offer polite but constructive criticism of some Democratic Party policies without worrying about being flagged as being anti-Democrat.

I also like the addition of a BlueSky button; however, as someone who likes to post animal video tweets in the DU Lounge (to cheer people up), I probably won't be able to continue that if "X" tweets won't be embedded anymore.
Posting a cute/funny animal video from X won't be the same if all I get to post is a link.
(Also, there are some well-known Democrats who still post on X, like Robert Reich)


orleans

(35,275 posts)
203. awww... well, thank you for being so persistent. this thank you went through and you're welcome
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 11:07 PM
Dec 11

evolves

(5,597 posts)
50. Thank you, EarlG and all DU Admins
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:46 PM
Dec 9

You make this site a safe and pleasant place to be.

I'd welcome a 2026/2028 forum dedicated to the Way Forward for Dems.

yardwork

(64,776 posts)
51. I'm in favor of a new forum to discuss the future of the Democratic Party.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:46 PM
Dec 9

I think the Party needs to make some changes and we need to discuss it here.

I like the other changes you're planning. I wish I could help with social media but I'm useless at it - although I agree that it's essential the Democrats get better at using it.

Fiendish Thingy

(18,820 posts)
55. Another vote for a "Future of the Democratic Party " forum
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:52 PM
Dec 9

And ten votes for reviving the “Creative Speculation” forum, so CT-ish posts can have a place to go without filling up General Discussion.

Different Drummer

(8,790 posts)
56. Question about X/Twitter embeds
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:57 PM
Dec 9

This is probably not the most intelligent question, but does this mean that *all* of the X/Twitter embeds will just show up as links or just the political content? The reason I'm asking is that I find a good amount of X/Twitter content that I have shared here, but none of it recently has been politically related since X/Twitter became so right-wing.

kentuck

(112,957 posts)
57. I agree with you that we need to discuss where the Party goes from here.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:59 PM
Dec 9

These are challenging times.

Spazito

(54,851 posts)
59. These are great changes...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:05 PM
Dec 9

and I fully support a separate forum to discuss the Future of the Democratic Party instead of it being in GD as the new forum can have a specific Statement of Purpose that will allow the discussion to be constructive while still keeping the trolls at bay.

Great work!

Kali

(55,878 posts)
60. sounds good. thanks for all you do
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:08 PM
Dec 9

count me as a vote/voice/request to restart Pic Of The Moment - or Day, or even Week. miss them! I need humor to get through this shit, I too am STILL reeling and in shock.

highplainsdem

(52,843 posts)
62. Thanks for the update, EarlG, and for everything you and Elad are doing. And add me to the DUers
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:15 PM
Dec 9

who think a separate forum to discuss where the party should go would be a good idea.

montanacowboy

(6,352 posts)
83. I am definitely on board
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:47 PM
Dec 9

with a new forum discussing the future of the Democratic Party. Thanks Admins.

SpankMe

(3,319 posts)
84. For the proposed "future-of-the-Democratic-party" forum, posting rules will have to be relaxed significant;y
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:52 PM
Dec 9

You ain't kidding when you say DU'ers have been less tolerant of criticism of Democratic politicians. They're less tolerant of a lot of things.

With all respect due to my fellow Democrats and libs, DU has strayed far from being a "free speech" forum. As an eligible juror, I've served on a lot of juries where people seem to interpret the most benign statements or questions as "divisive group attacks" or "parroting Republican talking points". Yes, we're partisan Democrats. But we've become so partisan that we've started eating our young in some threads here on DU for the crime of questioning a Democratic policy or preferring one Democrat's approach to another more liberal Democrat's approach.

It's sad. I've proffered certain criticisms - mostly in a constructive way, but sometimes with emotion - and have been attacked by iconic DU'ers whom I've respected and agreed with for years. It sucks when a DU'er that you're a fan of comes out and attacks you based on a misinterpretation of what you've said, or applying a level of sensitivity so high that there's no way you could have put it more delicately.

Some DU'ers can get quite prickly. I've had to post less because of it. The future-of-the-Democratic-Party forum will be a minefield in this puritanical climate. All options will have to be on the table if we're going to take this country back from the manifest evil of the Republican party and Trump's administration of hate, corruption and authoritarianism. That means feathers will get ruffled. We have to lower the censorship threshold so we can put some winning ideas on the table.

EarlG

(22,639 posts)
111. DU has never, ever been a "free speech" forum
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:36 PM
Dec 9

It has always been moderated to one degree or another.

That said, I agree that people posting in a forum specifically set up to discuss the future direction of the Democratic Party should probably need to be prepared to have a thicker skin. If alerts are a problem, my initial solution would simply be to be more lenient approving appeals (depending on their nature) in that forum. Personal attacks would still not be acceptable, but stronger criticism of Democrats should be allowed. If that doesn't work out, I'd consider other solutions.

I think we should all understand that the next four years are likely to be more contentious than the last eight, since the party needs to reassess and rebuild. But DU survived through all those difficult conversations in the past. We can handle this.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
85. Support that discussions of where the Party should go next...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:54 PM
Dec 9

should be in a new forum.

Might help with troll control if we have a designated area, too. Or not. Who knows. I'm sure library girl won't leave until she dies or loses all of her fingers and can't figure out how voice to text works.

But I digress.

Won't use the reply rec anymore with the change. I like that it's anonymous.

I'll help with SoMe if you want me.

Recommendations for other things that I thought about are up-thread. Look for the hearts ❤️ and 📣.

If I think of anything else I will let you know.

Looking forward to the changes. Keep the brain plasticity flowing.

Thanks for everything.

❤️pants

nmmi

(216 posts)
164. "Won't use the reply rec anymore with the change. I like that it's anonymous." - Me too: I like the anonymity
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 11:06 PM
Dec 9

When it's not anonymous, I will still use reply rec, but not as often as before.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
169. I'm glad to know that I'm not the only one. ...
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:27 AM
Dec 10

I also used it to keep up with what I read. I used it like a bookmark for the thread.

I could take a break or if I needed to do something. I could even just use it to stop and think about what I read and if I wanted to reply, what to say. I also used it to mark places I wanted to return to and reread sometimes.

And of course, I used it for recs. Especially if I was responding to a friend and if I had strong feelings about the post.

I'm glad you replied. I feel like someone understands me. Thank you, nmmi. ❤️

nmmi

(216 posts)
173. I suppose it will be retroactive too, so that all one's reply recs will be exposed since the beginning of DU4
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 01:49 AM
Dec 10

when the feature was first introduced.

I often thought of the beach analogy at low tide -- where when the water leaves -- the naked swimmers are left exposed, and I kinda wondered if some day that would happen with reply recs. I suspect we'll find out tomorrow (or today, depending on the time zone, Tuesday anyway) when the changes are expected to be implemented.

Edited to add - and thanks for bringing up the topic.

TBF

(34,761 posts)
86. New forum for dem party needed - and may attract new members
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:56 PM
Dec 9

I think we need that. I would keep it admin moderated, out of MIRT purview if you want to allow many voices.

TBF

(34,761 posts)
88. Also a fan of Bluesky -
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:59 PM
Dec 9

right now it's a big like & follow convention ... but I think it will get better as people get their followers and settle in. I like it better than Threads and X already because it's a left of center crowd.

Mike Nelson

(10,375 posts)
94. Like! Like! Like!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:12 PM
Dec 9

... I like the X and BlueSky changes!
... I like the idea about making DU bigger on other social media!
... I like the new forum idea!

Blue Dawn

(959 posts)
95. Thank you.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:24 PM
Dec 9

I so appreciate all that you do to keep DU current and also user-friendly.

Again, thank you.

Eugene

(62,781 posts)
96. Great, EarlG and Elad!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:29 PM
Dec 9

I'm in testing the waters mode on Bluesky.

Looking forward to the changes.

solara

(3,873 posts)
97. Thank you for all you do
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:45 PM
Dec 9

I really admire the work you do here, even though I'm such a Luddite I may not understand it all..

You keep it all real, or as real as it can be in these days..I love DU and I love being able to access the comments, the news and to read whatever is written here which is usually inspired. It's a beautiful gift to this community. so


With gratitude, I thank you

virgdem

(2,210 posts)
100. I fully support a forum where the future of
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 04:52 PM
Dec 9

the democratic party can be open for discussion. Great idea.

JHB

(37,469 posts)
101. Add another vote in favor of a "future of the Democratic Party" forum with looser rules in some areas
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:06 PM
Dec 9

We can't advocate for ways to move forward and get on track without getting into things that, shall we say, didn't pan out as well in practice as they did in theory. Some things need to be said forthrightly without triggering another round of "Pretty Pony Wars".

That said, looser rules don't mean "none'. Keep it respectful.

quaint

(3,653 posts)
103. I support a new forum to discuss The future of the Democratic Party.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:10 PM
Dec 9

Thank you for everything. The older I get, the more important DU is for me.

MustLoveBeagles

(12,695 posts)
104. Thank you for removing Twitter
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:16 PM
Dec 9

I think a separate section about the party's future is a good idea.

William769

(55,883 posts)
105. I have shyed away from posting in DU since the election because the direction
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:21 PM
Dec 9

discussions were heading (meaning Monday morning quarterbacking). Some people seem to have had it down pat.

I for one want to hear from the new leaders of our party and where they want to take our party (after all we have voted for these people to to do that very thing).

IMHO discussing "The future of the Democratic Party" in any forum here will come of no good. Yes, I am an old member and not wet behind the ears when it comes to fighting for Democratic values. After all that's what the future of the Democratic party should be all about.

I don't want this post to be all negative, so I will end with this HOPE.

P.S. I love the "Post-election DU software upgrades"!

Lunabell

(7,065 posts)
115. Great news!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:46 PM
Dec 9

Yes, to the new forum on the future of the Democratic party. There's a lot that needs to be said without fear of repercussions.

But, we still need to maintain decorum and no flaming each other with nastiness. But, if I want to say a big fuck you to Democratic politicians, I want to be able to say what I want about public figures.

And to hell with musk and zuckerberg!! Thanks for those changes.

SCantiGOP

(14,303 posts)
116. Strongly agree with shunning Xtwitter.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 05:50 PM
Dec 9

And would see the utility of a forum just to discuss the future of the Party.
Thanks for all you guys do.

Takket

(22,669 posts)
118. all good stuff!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 06:07 PM
Dec 9

And thank you so much for the bluesky integration! I've been wanting that for a long time. Lots of stuff on there i want to share but people can get testy with you on DU if you just post a link to something.

125. We need the ability to analyze the paths forward for the Democratic Party.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 07:02 PM
Dec 9

Not going to get into it here Mr. G, but if we have this subforum to examine our way forward, it should be exempt from alerting and actively moderated, so that certain cliques can't dominate the space that SHOULD be reserved for judgment-free and legitimate examinations of the party path as a whole.

Thank you for your consideration and time. And thank you for your continued efforts to support Democracy.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
141. I don't know if you've...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:33 PM
Dec 9

Ever joined MIRT but I have and don't think an alert free zone is realistic. We have TOS that need enforcement. Interesting thought though, HH.

❤️

147. I'm not saying a lawless zone. Just one without juries.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:51 PM
Dec 9

Mirt and admins could do whatever they wanted to secure the sanctity of du. But similar to the various specific individual groups, a forum for "how do we move forward" should have some protection against random alert hit squads.

littlemissmartypants

(25,910 posts)
151. I think any place...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:11 PM
Dec 9

Known to not have moderation by definition is lawless. It would likely become a magnet for bad actors.

There are many, many bad actors that do nothing but spread anarchy and disrupt as much as possible. That's all that they do, all the time. It's like they see it as their life's calling. Most are really proud of themselves, too.

Individual groups have rules and hosts, too. So they too are moderated.

There are very few hit squad alerts and those that occur are usually blatantly obvious.

I'd have to look at an example of what you're proposing because at this point, I don't see how it would work.

Thanks for your reply!

❤️

154. That's all fair. You and Earl G know more than I.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:19 PM
Dec 9

Sorry, I'm just in bed and can't respond properly. Thank you for the dialogue though

Dyedinthewoolliberal

(15,944 posts)
126. Regarding discussion of the Party etc
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 07:08 PM
Dec 9

I would like to see a "Platform" forum where we could all talk about what should the platform should look like and figure out ways to communicate the information to the DLCC or whomever it is that is responsible for it.

Cheezoholic

(2,647 posts)
129. Hard vote for a separate forum thread for issues concerning the party
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 07:17 PM
Dec 9

Its bound to get a bit heated and I personally think keeping these discussions in the confines of their own forum is for everyone's best interest. I'd prefer not to see GD gummed up with these discussions'. Besides being very important to all of us moving forward there are bound to be some very heated debates, while maybe necessary, they should be confined to their own space within the site. Plus, GD is the the most visible part of the site from the perspective of the web. I would vote for even going as far as making that forum a members only forum, not readable without joining.

Thanx for you and everyone's hard work. I did sign up for Bsky but don't ask me how that SM stuff works lol. I quit FB in 2010!

keepthemhonestO

(458 posts)
131. Here here
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 08:01 PM
Dec 9

To a lame duck session immediately.

Personally would prefer people talking about the next "election " in a forum.

Also did I miss if we started a forum about all the Russian interference ( bomb threats)irregularities and voter suppression, maybe there should be a post election talk about securing our vote. We are the only "Democratic country" that doesn't hand count our ballots. All that kind of talk in a forum for like minded folk would be ideal.

Thanks for all you do.

Cosmo Blues

(2,807 posts)
132. Seem like good ideas
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 08:05 PM
Dec 9

Thanks for being a thinker. I haven't posted much politically because of the heightened sensitivity here. I did post on Blue Sky that people know they should leave X and tick tock, glad to see some are, in a sense. You've created a good place

133. This must have been...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 08:33 PM
Dec 9

an enormous headache for you to accomplish; but, you did it and did it well. I am sure that the vast majority of DUers appreciate it and all the other things you and Elad do for us. Thank you!

HereForTheParty

(300 posts)
135. Great job, and I'd like to see the new forum
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 08:47 PM
Dec 9

Some are intolerant of criticism that is intended as constructive, or just self-reflective.

Moosepoop

(2,006 posts)
136. All excellent moves forward!!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 08:59 PM
Dec 9

I agree that DU needs to have a presence on various social media. I think your request for volunteers to help in that area got lost among all the other information in your post. Maybe consider making that part of it a stand alone post of its own? It might get more attention and response that way?

And please DO continue with the Pic of the Moment!!! Both here and on social media. They are gems, they're a highlight of DU, and they're a draw to this site when seen by others.

Thank you, Earl G and Elad, for this website!!!

Baron2024

(263 posts)
137. Following This Thread
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:00 PM
Dec 9

Thanks to all of the people that make DU what it is- a safe haven for Democrats and Progressives.

RainCaster

(11,657 posts)
146. A forum about the future of the party- YES! 👍
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 09:46 PM
Dec 9

Earl, that's a great idea. I agree wholeheartedly that we need this. As for the rules of engagement, I think we should be open to all ideas, as long as they are presented thoughtfully and nobody is being attacked.

Jack Valentino

(1,510 posts)
162. I will be disappointed if Twitter embeds no longer appear, regardless of what happens
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 10:51 PM
Dec 9

with adding Bluesky (which I do support).

Likewise with removing Twitter as a "share" option--- I don't see what sense that makes at all, if you really want to improve the visibility of this site on social media.

There are still plenty of liberals on Twitter, and I'm one of them. I appreciate being able to see and read the Twitter embeds without having to click-through to a link.

I really HATE when people post a "link" and nothing else. This change would convert every Twitter post to yet another "link" with nothing else.

Hell, rather than removing Twitter embeds, I would like to see it made impossible to post a stand-alone link without a summary of said links, with a minimum character requirement!


I support maintaining a liberal presence on Twitter, as opposed to those who incessantly complain about Twitter embeds on this site--
they are just louder and more repetitive than those of us who have been happy enough with things as they are!

fishwax

(29,328 posts)
165. Thank you for all you do ... and yes, I think a dedicated forum for the future of the party is a great idea
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 11:11 PM
Dec 9

Jack Valentino

(1,510 posts)
166. GREAT IDEA about enlisting some DUers to administrate the site's social media accounts!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 11:28 PM
Dec 9

(I am not volunteering, others would be better and more consistent at it).

As an aside, EarlG, I have LOVED your "pictures of the day" when you have issued them, and often have re-posted them to my own social media accounts! I would urge you to continue them--- doesn't have to be daily, that's a lot of pressure, obviously--- but whenever you are inspired to make one on any particular topic! (My personal favorite was after the SOTU, something about Biden eating the speaker's lunch, I think). I hope you will continue to do them periodically, when inspiration strikes--- clearly there will probably be a lot of comedic material generated by the pending administration...



Back to the proposed social media account enlisted administrators-- I would suggest
one or more persons be appointed for each social account--

and that they maintain a separate public email address, a Gmail or whatever
(and that those addresses be published here periodically)
specifically designated ONLY for recommendations from DU members for specific postings to
the social media to which they are assigned. It would be an "idea file" for those social admins
from which they could choose to draw material for postings, edited or not
(with no obligation to re-post any such suggestions, only to review them--- but---
that would allow DU members to contribute ideas for the social postings from this site!)

If I was one of such volunteers (which I am not but I presume there would be many candidates), I would appreciate that input which would help to create several postings per day on whatever social media account--- as I presume you have experienced with your "picture of the day", it can be difficult to come up with ideas every single day, but I think such an arrangement would enable the admins of the social media accounts to make several postings per day to such accounts, without having to come up with them all by themselves--- and consistent and repetitive postings to social medias are key to the reach of any such accounts.


I vehemently advocate that Twitter be included in this, and administrated by someone who is willing to make that fight--- whatever some DUers may think about that arena, we should not surrender it to the far right--- and the DU account there should be re-activated by someone who wants to commit to that fight! (There seem to be plenty of DUers who are committed to remaining there, as the frequency of Twitter embeds will attest)

B.See

(3,831 posts)
167. Thanks for all your efforts at
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 11:41 PM
Dec 9

improving our DU experience.

Having a haven such as DU, of generally like minded individuals, wherein we can express our thoughts, feelings, hopes, and fears has surely been a blessing, even a catharsis - in keeping many sane, in an age of insanity. And it has been an honour to have been a part of it.

Re social media, I know little or nothing about it and have never been on Twitter, Facebook, Tok and the like. Can't even watch most viddies because I get some 'prove you're not a bot' thingy. So wouldn't be able to help there.

Re more open give and take discussions of where the Party should go next, I'd be more in favour of a special space (forum) with its own set of rules that'd allow for those kinds of discussions. That way, members can decided for themselves whether to venture in.

ramapo

(4,744 posts)
183. New forum, no Twitter
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 08:36 AM
Dec 10

I am gradually crawling out of my self-imposed hole of isolation but can only tolerate the Energy/Environment forum as the rest just makes me sick.

By all means, remove Twitter integration and replace as possible with BlueSky. I was never one for Twitter but joined BlueSky right after the election. Lots of good stuff there.

Yes to a new forum for a new generation.

Thanks for everything

sellitman

(11,688 posts)
184. I left X when he allowed the Nazis back
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 09:43 AM
Dec 10

Haven't missed it at all.

The separate forum sounds like a great idea.

Cheers,

Kevin

Bobstandard

(1,711 posts)
194. Zelenskyy's Syria statement today is a Tweet
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 06:38 PM
Dec 10

Lots of important people in lots of important countries rely on Twitter to communicate with the world, with us. Zelensky made a powerful statement today about Syria and Putins role helping Assad make it a hellish prison state. He made it on Twitter. We need to keep hearing voices like his any way we can. Until the world is on Bluesky or something else, Twitter, no matter how odious it is, remains an important channel that sometimes delivers info we need fast. Making the information throughput slower isn’t a good idea. I say keep making it easy to embed but make it clear it’s a last resort sort of thing.

ancianita

(38,881 posts)
195. Yes, I'm all for a Future of the Unified Democratic Party Forum, the sooner the better.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 07:00 PM
Dec 10

Before Jan 20, 2025, if possible.

Thank you and Elad for your long term commitment to strengthening democracy. If that works through Democrats who are Underground, fine -- even a billionaire donor might be sold enough by the forum's ideas to invest in the site. Because gaming systems against human freedoms and democracy has got to be stopped. Even Cards Against Humanity is in a fight against Elon.

CousinIT

(10,491 posts)
196. Has the update happened? I'm not seeing the new stuff yet.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 07:23 PM
Dec 10

No rush but I am excited for the changes!

FireUpChips10

(23,988 posts)
197. Thanks for all you do! A couple thoughts:
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 10:21 PM
Dec 10

I've done social media for a number of organizations (both paid and unpaid).

I agree we need to have conversations on where we go as a Party, and a separate forum would be a good idea.

boston bean

(36,529 posts)
198. I like the idea of a forum. We just lost an election to a convicted felon.
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 04:39 PM
Dec 11

Some hard truths and ideas need to be openly discussed without fear or retribution.

Sympthsical

(10,404 posts)
199. A separate forum would become an alert-drenched slapfest
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 04:59 PM
Dec 11

Let's be honest. Criticism, which would be required in recognizing mistakes and steering the party forward with an eye on the current electorate and future elections, is barely welcome now in GD. The line between bashing and criticism are whatever four random people say it is at any given moment.

Concentrating any criticism into one forum in such a way would probably just give a sitting target for alerting and juries nonstop.

"These conversations may not be easy."

They're barely managed now. I don't see how having a forum for it would serve purpose. "We did nothing wrong. No notes!" is already the overwhelming sentiment that drowns out most of these conversations. How could such a forum be successfully navigated into anything productive?

This space is what it is. And thoughtful discussion about how the Democratic Party may need to change and adjust to meet reality is not a welcome topic generally that usually devolves into extreme volatility. Dedicating an entire forum towards that end sounds like providing a field for the tire fire.

Abolishinist

(2,075 posts)
202. Well said. On the one hand, it would be 'interesting' for some of us
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 09:14 PM
Dec 11

to have the ability to venture a bit beyond what is 'acceptable' for 4 out of 7, but that can't happen without a change in the rules, and that ain't gonna happen. And on the other hand, they had warts.

carpetbagger

(4,890 posts)
204. We need a forum for critique.
Thu Dec 12, 2024, 01:26 PM
Dec 12

I say that having been on MIRT and seeing removed posts that I agree with. I think the party and the center-left-to-social-democrat movement needs a fundamentally new approach. This site becomes harmful if it hamstrings the ability to prepare for and respond to the next Occupy Wall Street moment.

devans00

(21 posts)
206. Geriatric Democratic Leadership Refuse to Step Aside
Tue Dec 17, 2024, 10:52 PM
Dec 17

Quote:
“ our old leaders are aging out, and a new crop of younger Democrats will soon rise to the top.”
— EarlG, on behalf of Elad -- the DU Administrators


Sadly, with the win of 74 year old (fighting esophagus cancer) Representative Gerry Connolly of Virginia to become top Democrat on the Oversight Committee over up and coming 34 year old star Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, it’s crystal clear the oldsters don’t plan to pass the torch until they turn to dust. No succession planning or easing new blood into leadership roles since they plan to live forever, apparently.

Of course, the hypocrisy of chasing Joe Biden out of the POTUS election campaign because he’s too old while keeping a death grip on power themselves, over a decade after most Americans are forced to retire, is breathtaking.

Democrats in Congress are bound and determined to kill any momentum and excitement built up by the beginning of the Kamala Harris - Tim Walz 2024 Presidential Election Campaign. The combination of Leadership and Consultants do just about anything anyone could think of to switch the passion and enthusiasm to off. When even more potential Democratic voters decide to sit out future elections: !

Latest Discussions»Help & Search»Announcements»Post-election DU upgrades...