Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

elleng

(136,880 posts)
Sat Jul 23, 2022, 04:17 PM Jul 2022

The Old New York Page

1955
Nathan's Famous (est. 1916) at Coney Island was founded by Polish immigrant Nathan Handwerker (1892–1974) with a $300 loan. He landed on Ellis Island in 1912.

He first worked as a roll slicer for Feltman's (1871-1954), selling Coney Island Red Hots. The term hot dog was banned then by Coney Island's Chamber of Commerce for connoting dog meat.

Eddie Cantor and Jimmy Durante convinced Nathan to leave Feltman's, and start his own stand, which sold hot dogs for 50% less at a nickel each.

Nathan's wife Ida was behind the hot dog ingredients, using her grandmother's secret spice recipe.
Servers in 1916 wore surgeon smocks to project an image of cleanliness. Nathan's promoted samples to doctors and nurses.
The meat packing industry had been scandalized by Upton Sinclair's The Jungle (1906) for corruption and lack of hygiene.

The hamburger did not make a comeback until world's first fast-food chain White Castle (1921), projecting whiteness (walls, uniforms, buildings) for cleanliness.
By 1920, 75,000 hot dogs were sold on weekends at Nathan's. Police regularly gave double-parked cars a break. Customers have included FDR, Stalin and Churchill (Nathan's takeout sent to Yalta -Updated).
From 1950s-2010s, Nathan's sold a popular Chow Mein Sandwich, originally from 1930s-40s Fall River (MA), popular with French-Canadians and Europeans, nostalgic for 1959-born local Emeril Lagasse.

RFK campaigned at Nathan's in 1964. In 1968, Nathan's expanded, eventually with 300 restaurants across the US, supplying supermarkets in 50 states. Nathan's would eventually expand to 17 nations worldwide.
Originally Nathan's became the official food vendor for Woodstock (1969) for 400,000 music fans, but bowed out when the festival location moved from Woodstock.
Nathan's hot dog eating contest became an annual event from 1972, watched by 2 million people in 2011 on ESPN.
Takeru Kobayashi won 2001-06 titles, and set 8 world records eating hot dogs, meatballs, Twinkies, tacos, hamburgers, pizza, ice cream and pasta.

On July 4, 2001, Kobayashi ate 50 hot dogs in 12 min. He reached 69 by 2011.
There was a legendary story of the first hot dog eating contest at Nathan's taking place on July 4, 1916, to determine which of 4 men was most patriotic. James Mullen won, eating 13 hot dogs in 12 mins. But the story was fictional.

Nathan's share price peaked at $41 in the 1970s, but dwindled to $1 during the 1981 recession, nearly collapsing.
There were loud calls to diversify, but Nathan's son Murray Handwerker stayed true to the hot dog. By 1986, Nathan's sold 20 stores and a packaged products business for $19 million.
Nathan's at Coney Island closed for the first time in 2012 after Hurricane Sandy and reopened again, teeming with business.

https://www.facebook.com/TheOldNewYorkPage/photos/a.493205104025672/5638259726186825/

5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Old New York Page (Original Post) elleng Jul 2022 OP
I especially like LaGuardia and the Artichoke Wars. 3Hotdogs Jul 2022 #1
Things I did on my visit to NYC, my hometown MyMission Jul 2022 #2
SO glad you went, and wrote about it! elleng Jul 2022 #3
It was my first time back in 17 years MyMission Jul 2022 #4
Glad you found it the same. elleng Jul 2022 #5

MyMission

(2,000 posts)
2. Things I did on my visit to NYC, my hometown
Sat Jul 23, 2022, 07:26 PM
Jul 2022

Last summer, on my 60th birthday, driving along Surf Ave with my brother, heading towards Brighton beach, I spotted Nathan's and said we had to stop. I got us each an order of fries, no hot dogs. That was the morning I arrived.

Stayed in NYC with a friend for 2 nights, during restaurant week, ate at 2 nice places but also managed to hit 2 pizza parlors. Nothing like NY pizza.

The other food highpoint was finding a Mr Softie ice cream truck stationed by a park, and enjoying a mixed vanilla and chocolate cone. I'd almost forgotten we stopped at Nathan's.

Thanks for the memories, and the interesting article.

elleng

(136,880 posts)
3. SO glad you went, and wrote about it!
Sat Jul 23, 2022, 07:31 PM
Jul 2022

MY hometown too, but haven't been back in MANY years. (Did attend high school reunion on Long Island 10? years ago, but not the same.)

MyMission

(2,000 posts)
4. It was my first time back in 17 years
Sat Jul 23, 2022, 07:56 PM
Jul 2022

Specifically to celebrate my 60th at the beach, see my foster brother who lives in NJ. I landed in Newark before 9 am, he was waiting. We'd thought to go to a NJ beach, but decided to drive to Brighton because we grew up going there. We had a lot of fun. I drove to NJ to see him 6 years ago, and we then drove upstate, but literally hadn't set foot in NYC since 2004.

Despite the changes, I found it much the same.

elleng

(136,880 posts)
5. Glad you found it the same.
Sat Jul 23, 2022, 08:01 PM
Jul 2022

Family friends lived in SheepHead Bay, so I recall vising there often, as a kid.

Daughter and kids live in NJ now, and visited them there often before covid; haven't been back in 2+ years.

Latest Discussions»Region Forums»New York»The Old New York Page