Jewish Group
Related: About this forum(JEWISH GROUP) An Arizona cemetery now requires mourners to leave before burial. A rabbi plans to sue.
At Jewish funerals, the final act is often the simplest: The casket is lowered into the earth, mourners take turns with a shovel, and the grave slowly fills. It is a moment many rabbis describe as the essence of burial the point at which ritual, grief and physical reality meet.
At a cemetery in Scottsdale, Arizona, that moment now does not happen.
A new safety policy at Paradise Memorial Gardens requires families to leave before a casket is lowered into the ground. Cemetery officials say the rule, which applies to all funerals, is necessary to prevent accidents, likely involving uneven ground, heavy equipment and mourners overcome with grief. But Jewish clergy say the policy interferes with a core religious ritual, and one local rabbi is preparing a lawsuit.
For Cindy Carpenter, 66, the dispute became painfully personal.
Her younger daughter, Chelsea, died at 33 of cancer in November. As Carpenter arranged the funeral, she and her husband purchased five burial plots at Paradise for their two daughters, themselves and Chelseas husband expecting the family would be buried together and according to Jewish practice. In total, the plots cost about $50,000, Carpenter said.
more...
Ilsa
(64,176 posts)Buyers agree to hold harmless the cemetery for allowing mourners to exercise their rituals.
Mosby
(19,480 posts)It's basically a Christian cemetery.
madaboutharry
(42,032 posts)The policy, including making people leave the premises, is extreme and draconian.
Mosby
(19,480 posts)It's one thing to try to address an apparent issue with people getting to close to the hole, but to make mourners leave the area entirely is just being purposely cruel. The manager even said that the new policies aren't consistent with "all religions traditions" so they don't even care that they are discriminating against Jewish customers.
There is an actual Jewish cemetery right nearby that is for the entire community, affiliated and unaffiliated. Called Mt. Sinai.
Eta there are reasons for not being in a Jewish cemetery, which i completely understand.