Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mucholderthandirt

(1,354 posts)
22. I don't believe this is a valid observation.
Sun Dec 22, 2024, 04:54 PM
Dec 22

Writing has typically been male, and almost completely cis white males. I believe we're just seeing an equalization of the field being more open to females, POC, a varied gender scale. Especially since self publishing has made is possible to bypass the traditional publishing path, which tended to self-regulate to exclude most of those "other" writers.

Also, more women are working in publishing as editors, agents and other roles than they ever could have hoped for, which is another hot spot. Women are leaving men out, choosing other women, minorities and so on, and it's just not fair, some men claim.

This has been a topic in the writing world for a long time. Mostly it seems to be started by male writers who believe people of less value are being allowed to publish books, pushing them out. But, readers are not a finite resource. More are being born everyday, and markets are opening up (thanks mostly to smart phones being more widely available at a lower cost) that we never dreamed of reaching.

I'm on the front line of self publishing, though I also follow some trad pub stuff. I see this kind of attitude almost daily, on both paths. It seems to follow along with the increasing vocal protests of incel men, and the MAGA movement. It's not safe anywhere, unless you are a cis white male, especially claiming to be Christian. Everyone is out to get them, and my guess is the turnout for Trump is the signal for them to become even worse.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

maybe most readers of fiction are women? nt msongs Dec 22 #1
Most readers are, indeed, female. Multiple studies and polls have shown this. mucholderthandirt Dec 22 #23
I don't think DeepWinter Dec 22 #2
I was going to post something about women in general being more creative and having better imaginations, and then..... EarnestPutz Dec 22 #3
Great post ... anciano Dec 22 #9
Thank you. Given the subject, I felt that I had to put in some effort. :) EarnestPutz Dec 22 #10
So men aren't reading these days? ananda Dec 22 #4
fewer men with degrees. bucolic_frolic Dec 22 #5
excuse me, MEN don't have the spare time? mainer Dec 22 #14
Does your library have a separate science fiction / fantasy section? RockRaven Dec 22 #6
I'm betting it's more 50/50 M/F in SF and fantasy mainer Dec 22 #13
The funny thing about SF? Of any type? Most readers are female, and these days, most writers as well. mucholderthandirt Dec 22 #24
CJ Cherryh and Julian May are two more AZSkiffyGeek Dec 22 #31
Hard sci-fi is probably closer to 90/10 AZSkiffyGeek Dec 22 #30
What a good suggestion!!! LAS14 Dec 22 #18
If you look at the nominees for the Hugo awards Retrograde Dec 22 #28
I'm not surprised. I read more than just about anyone I know. Aristus Dec 22 #33
Are you counting journalists? lame54 Dec 22 #7
I don't understand the question. I was surveying fiction books. nt LAS14 Dec 22 #34
Men are writing Jilly_in_VA Dec 22 #8
Men favor non-fiction, women favor fiction Sympthsical Dec 22 #11
The majority of fiction readers are women mainer Dec 22 #12
Their parents pitch a bitch if they want to major in the humanities? Iris Dec 22 #15
Also that. nt eppur_se_muova Dec 22 #17
This is a result of which genre is dominating the fiction market. LudwigPastorius Dec 22 #16
LOL Just not true overall. And don't forget, self publishing has over-taken romance from trad pub. mucholderthandirt Dec 22 #25
To those of you who have observed... LAS14 Dec 22 #19
I'm female, I read a lot, and I almost never read fiction. milestogo Dec 22 #20
Well, in the mid 70s, it didnt take me long to figure out that MineralMan Dec 22 #21
I don't believe this is a valid observation. mucholderthandirt Dec 22 #22
Who is on your radar these days in terms of great fiction writers? Mike 03 Dec 22 #29
There are some great sci-fi writers tackling global warming AZSkiffyGeek Dec 22 #32
Maybe because men are no longer encouraged to be fully educated? haele Dec 22 #26
My observation... there has only been ONE huge female crossover author... WarGamer Dec 22 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What's with male fiction ...»Reply #22