Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,604 posts)
5. Hmm...
Fri Aug 6, 2021, 10:03 PM
Aug 2021

At 17 I was a 135 lb skinny kid. I learned to fire an M-1 Garand. The first step was to spend 2 days with my friend and instructor reloading several hundred rounds of .30-06. I got an education in the chemical and mechanical details of the bullet. After each in the reloading there was a loud and clear announcement that the smoking lamp was out. Then came some basic education at the indoor PANG range: basics, more safety instruction, how to avoid M-1 thumb... all this after firing .22 M-1 training rifles for months. We went to an outdoor range to fire the Garands. Firing .30-06 in 50 ft indoor range with brick walls and concrete ceilings and floors is a bad idea even with the earmuffs. But with firing disabled we have an exercise indoors to get used to the kick of the rifle. Laying prone in a shooting position with the firing mechanism disabled, my instructor walked around in front of me and kicked the end of the barrel.

Short story, the muzzle energy of Garand was more double that of the AR. We reloaded 220 grain .30 cal ammo. IIRC the more than double figures compare 77 grain .223 compared to 220 grain .30-06 at 1300 ft-lbs (and change) to about 3000 ft-lbs, respectively.

My memory is that the kick of the M-1 was considerable but fell a bit short of Mr. McCallum's AR dramatics.
BTW I didn't miss the "assault rifle" mistake in there either.

I'm thinking the author's previous shooting experience may have been limited to paintball.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I agree the description is over-dramatized, but the AR15 concept was never meant for deer hunting. Atticus Aug 2021 #1
The AR15 platform can fire many different rounds. Some suitable for hunting deer. Kaleva Aug 2021 #7
I was responding to this in the OP: Atticus Aug 2021 #8
Ok. The .223 Remington is considered to be insufficient by many to cleanly kill deer Kaleva Aug 2021 #10
To be pedantic, .308 is not a chambering for the AR-15, but rather the AR-10. Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #12
Actually, my headline wasn't technically accurate as the rifle in question was an HK, Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #11
Article does say it was an AR15 style rifle. Kaleva Aug 2021 #14
One presumes that had he been firing a 7.62x51, he would have Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #15
LOL! Kaleva Aug 2021 #18
He'd apparently would have passed out after firing my MosinNagant M-44 in 7.6254mmR lol EX500rider Aug 2021 #23
AR rifle intelpug Aug 2021 #26
Is he sure he didn't sarisataka Aug 2021 #2
I agree WA-03 Democrat Aug 2021 #3
These things are always so poorly done. WhiskeyGrinder Aug 2021 #4
Hmm... discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2021 #5
Wow. 220's in an M-1 wasn't a very wise choice. yagotme Aug 2021 #35
Sarge had a manual and a few hundred 220s to use up. discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2021 #37
Pass everything but a gas station??? yagotme Sep 2021 #40
What can I say? Gas was cheap. discntnt_irny_srcsm Sep 2021 #41
The word of the day is melm00se Aug 2021 #6
This may be a little hyperbole. beemerphill Aug 2021 #9
A Pulitzer Prize winning author pushing an agenda? Now you're just being cynical. Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #13
That's not the sad part. beemerphill Aug 2021 #21
It's happening as you read this. discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2021 #22
Not even an AR-50 does that. LiberatedUSA Aug 2021 #16
Let's not forget a journalist's description of his firing of an AR-15, some 5 years ago: Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #17
LOL n/t LiberatedUSA Aug 2021 #19
I just figured out what that reminds me of. LiberatedUSA Aug 2021 #20
journalist's description intelpug Aug 2021 #27
Thanks for treating journalists like shit, Gun Enthusiasts. Paladin Aug 2021 #24
Maybe this would help discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2021 #25
This thread is pointing out the absurdity of 2 articles. Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #28
Yeah, sure. Paladin Aug 2021 #29
Mea culpa. My apologies for introducing quantitative data. n/t discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2021 #30
Behold the earth-shattering recoil of the AR-15! Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #31
You owe it to yourself to find a better spokesman. Paladin Aug 2021 #32
Oik then, let me speak with experience, MarineCombatEngineer Aug 2021 #33
When all else fails, attack the messenger rather than the message. Dial H For Hero Aug 2021 #34
LOL PTWB Sep 2021 #44
Have you fired an AR-15? yagotme Aug 2021 #36
Yes, I've fired an AR-15. Paladin Aug 2021 #38
Unique, to show a point... yagotme Sep 2021 #39
And here you are, all this time later, getting mileage out of trashing him. Paladin Sep 2021 #42
Just explaining my "unique" way of firing an AR-15, yagotme Sep 2021 #43
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»Journalist describes the ...»Reply #5