Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jewish Group

cilla4progress

(25,997 posts)

15. Well, so much so in my family,

Reply to Grumpy Old Guy (Original post)

Mon Feb 28, 2022, 10:46 AM

Feb 2022

we celebrated no Jewish holidays nor traditions - only secular Christmas.

My sister and I were raised in the Ethical Culture Society "religion," based in humanism. Many adherents were of Jewish background.

https://ethical.nyc/

In later years, my parents started attending a Unitarian Universalist fellowship - very progressive, no dogma per se..I then did, too.

My daughter did 23andme and found she was half Jewish (my side) - not Russian. Of course!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

20 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I always thought I was a Russian Jew. [View all] Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2022 OP

Journalist (and old time DUer) Larisa Alexandrova is from Odessa. blm Feb 2022 #1

Same with my MIL. She always told her children she was Russian MaryMagdaline Feb 2022 #2

I don't recall specific geography being discussed; elleng Feb 2022 #3

That clip says it all, doesn't it? Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2022 #10

Oh my GOODNESS, how lucky, you knew your great grandmother! elleng Feb 2022 #13

I was very fortunate. Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2022 #14

What a beautiful story. JudyM Mar 2022 #16

That is also a beautiful story. Grumpy Old Guy Mar 2022 #19

I'm sure it has affected you, my dear Grumpy Old Guy... CaliforniaPeggy Feb 2022 #4

My great grandfather RockCreek Feb 2022 #5

I'm half Ukrainian but never felt any connection unblock Feb 2022 #6

The pogroms didn't help build any connection, for sure. JudyM Mar 2022 #17

Thanks! unblock Mar 2022 #18

I think of myself as Ashkenazi because when my grandparents left Europe around WWI they were mucifer Feb 2022 #7

That's true. Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2022 #11

Russia had an area called the Pale of Settlement where modern Ukraine exists. Lots of Jews Karadeniz Feb 2022 #8

I, too, learned yesterday from my older sister that cilla4progress Feb 2022 #9

It's strange that several of us had similar experiences. Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2022 #12

Well, so much so in my family, cilla4progress Feb 2022 #15

Many Jews were brought up thinking this because they were. Behind the Aegis Mar 2022 #20