Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Movies

In reply to the discussion: Aleksei German [View all]

ananda

(31,129 posts)
1. Pasternak resonates in Hard to Be a God
Sat Feb 28, 2015, 10:13 PM
Feb 2015

In Aleksei German’s film “Hard to Be a God,” the character of Don Rumata .. at one point fairly early on.. reiterates some lines of poetry that begin as follows: “The murmurs ebb, onto the stage I enter.” I thought he was remembering lines written by a poet of Irukan, now dead (because the Greys are killing off all the literates on the planet currently in a stage eerily reminiscent of our own Dark Ages); but as it turns out, these are lines that originated on Don Rumata’s home planet, Earth, written by the great Boris Pasternak himself. Oddly enough, these lines remained with me throughout the rest of the film, working in a kind of strange self-fulfillment as the beleaguered and frustrated Don Rumata struggles to be a “god” so to speak.

Yet this “god” is more of a christo verso acting as a kind of reverse or backwards version of the biblical god. At one point there is a scene right out of the gospel mirroring the Palm Sunday scene of Christ on the donkey; but on Irukan, Don Rumata, facing the rear, is led on a donkey through a constantly wet, muddy and rotting huis clos space reminiscent of Brueghel gone wet, gray, wild, and grotesque. Much later, after much travail and killing, he is sitting in a dirty pool of water enclosed by rock walls and rubble, with a couple of people on the bank, saying philosophically: "It's so hard; it's hard to be a god." So you will be able to see how this poem of Pasternak’s – “The Saturday Poem: Hamlet" -- resonates not only through Don Rumata’s psyche but also that of the viewer brought so closely into his telescoped “stable” of fools, idiots, lobotomized killers, and poignant innocents:


The murmurs ebb; onto the stage I enter.
I am trying, standing in the door,
To discover in the distant echoes
What the coming years may hold in store.


The nocturnal darkness with a thousand
Binoculars is focused onto me.
Take away this cup, O Abba, Father,
Everything is possible to thee.


I am fond of this thy stubborn project,
And to play my part I am content.
But another drama is in progress,
And, this once, O let me be exempt.


But the plan of action is determined,
And the end irrevocably sealed.
I am alone; all round me drowns in falsehood:
Life is not a walk across a field.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Aleksei German [View all] ananda Feb 2015 OP
Pasternak resonates in Hard to Be a God ananda Feb 2015 #1
Aleksei German michaljohnson Apr 2015 #2
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Movies»Aleksei German»Reply #1