Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Why? [View all]

ancianita

(38,880 posts)
27. It's a rigged question to claim to be an "unapologetic atheist" and still expect a 'theological' answer to "Why?"
Thu Dec 26, 2024, 07:31 PM
Thursday

-- rigged because it's a question that in itself presupposes the existence of a God, even for the sake of argument.

I could argue that General Discussion isn't the proper context for questions that whole books are written about; I also could give you the benefit of the doubt after you answer this: why do humans have free will?

Well educated, well read, well traveled, I was a Four Horseman Atheist for at least two decades.




Then my heart opened up. I read and studied more because I believe in lifelong learning.
If you're serious about "Why?" then you'll make the effort to dig into 20 centuries of explanation.
Here's a good start




In it are enough centuries of documentation, timelines that prove Christianity is the only fact-based religion of any other belief system. In this book are more than enough answers to your "why?" to give God the benefit of human doubt.

Once you've read this book, you might start questioning your doubts, even.

If you're fair you might ask yourself "Is it reasonable to doubt that Christianity is true in light of all the evidence?" You might come to think probably not. You might come to think that in light of the evidence, you have more doubts about atheism and every other non-Christian belief system. Given the evidence, they are not reasonable. Christianity is. You might seriously reconsider humanity's 4,000 years long spiritual/social ordering process from just "gods consciousness" to God revealing Its/His existence as the God who made trillions of universes macro to micro; the God who established the stardust on this planet as made in His image, though containing all the stuff of those universes, the God who directly delivered commandments, which then became laws, courts, judges, direct eyewitness testimony, juries, etc. to humans, to create order out of human power chaos.


I could argue that for you to expect best and final answers here in a forum context is also unreasonable.
Then again, as a former atheist, I could say
a) go outside this forum's comfort zone, maybe open up your heart, because
b) what have you got to lose?





Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Why? [View all] angrychair Thursday OP
For its own amusement. Susan Calvin Thursday #1
For amusement. The same reason I would assemble a Lionel train set. 3Hotdogs Thursday #17
A couple of thoughts.... anciano Thursday #2
While I do not believe in any higher power angrychair Thursday #9
I don't know, but George Carlin observed God is supposed to be an omnipotent, all powerful, all knowing being, but.. surfered Thursday #3
Yeah. Fuck all. If Jesus was a smart as we think he is, he would tune into Dave Ramsey every day 3Hotdogs Thursday #19
Humanity was in it's childhood... Think. Again. Thursday #4
Control Blue Full Moon Thursday #5
According to the Bible, we are not supposed to make an image of God. Clouds Passing Thursday #6
Good questions LogDog75 Thursday #7
If God was that smart that he wanted the choir of angels and harps, why not just make a choir of angels and harps. That, 3Hotdogs Thursday #20
Either you believe in God, or you believe ... Intractable Thursday #8
I agree with you LogDog75 Thursday #12
From your analogy, the question is where did the two-feet of dirt come from? Intractable Thursday #15
Message auto-removed Name removed Yesterday #42
Divinity JoseBalow Yesterday #43
I have faith not religion Marthe48 Thursday #10
I think when we die we are dead. No complex or convoluted explanations needed. elocs Thursday #28
I have the answer. bluescribbler Thursday #11
Matter and energy is, was, and always will be... GiqueCee Thursday #13
"Why?" JoseBalow Thursday #14
Now, that's what I call "putting things into perspective." Intractable Thursday #16
wonderful pics... and then came that last one and i lol'd! nt orleans Thursday #22
In fairness, True Dough Thursday #32
That question was answered at the end of "Venus on the Half Shell" by Kilgore Trout Martin Eden Thursday #18
Art Maeve Thursday #21
Love RainCaster Thursday #23
Good perspective angrychair Thursday #33
Why? Roy Rolling Thursday #24
Nice perspective angrychair Thursday #34
I am an atheist too Americanme Thursday #25
Don't overthink it because that's a fool's errand. n/t elocs Thursday #29
"I think men created the creator, to answer any questions they had no answers for." Talitha Thursday #31
Why didn't Jesus at least educate the people about germs or even the concept of zero ? rickford66 Thursday #26
It's a rigged question to claim to be an "unapologetic atheist" and still expect a 'theological' answer to "Why?" ancianita Thursday #27
I thank you for the thoughtful angrychair Thursday #37
I see. Understood. Thank you. ancianita 17 hrs ago #45
I would also ask, what if? Buddyzbuddy Thursday #30
Thank you angrychair Yesterday #38
Thank you. I agree with you. Buddyzbuddy Yesterday #40
Why is not the question; it's the answer. usonian Thursday #35
To those of us who have had experience with some level of spiritual dimensions, atheism in today's Karadeniz Thursday #36
Thank you angrychair Yesterday #39
Yep ! Karadeniz 20 hrs ago #44
Why? To be blunt... To see it happen. See full post for context. Hellbound Hellhound Yesterday #41
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why?»Reply #27